American Tamale Pie

Both Jim and I stake claim to Mexican cooking “know-how” in our household. Our reasonings, mind you, are totally unfounded. Jim thinks he’s Mexi-King because he spent a year in Southern California eating at “authentic” taco stands and burrito joints (and also doing drugs, which is why I discount his authority of taste during that time). Me, I think I’m the top tortilla because I’m generally the more-food-knowledgeable one, I’ve dated a few Spanish guys, and more importantly, I have a thing for Spanish literature, especially authors like Borges (who’s actually Argentinian), Márquez (who’s Colombian). No, not Mexican, so yes, that point is totally worthless, but somewhere in my unthinking brain I associate my fondness of translations (note: I can’t even read Spanish) with my ability to cook.

Moreover, we’re both highly competitive. Most of the time, we are able to function because we have different specialties–me cooking, him writing–but because I also write and he cooks, we have some overlap that usually ends in long conversations about why one knows more than the other.

The dish I’m blogging about today, however, proves that while we may know how to eat Mexican food, neither of us can hold bragging rights on how to cook it. Especially not me, since I’m the one who cooked this.

It started with me craving Chicken Pot Pie, then wanting to switch the chicken for beef, then wondering what this could be called—beef pot pie, burger pie, etc—and after a google search of “beef instead of chicken pot pie,” finding a bunch of recipes for Tamale Pie. One look at the words Monterey Jack Cheese, and Tamale Pie became dinner.

Instead of scoping out the many I’m-sure-delicious recipes on the internet, I decided to give this recipe a go on my own—confident that my Mexican-prowess would result in something sabroso!

The end product of my experiment wasn’t Mexican, though it was flavorsome. We wolfed the pie down in one satisfying sitting and my tamale pie was deigned a success, but something was off about the flavors, and we couldn’t pinpoint what wasn’t Mexican enough about it.

Wanting to know whether I had been way-off with my attempt at the dish, we turned to wiki-pedia, finding that Tamale Pie is only a “meat mixture covered with cornbread topping that resembles a Mexican dish” and actually has American origin. So, my dish is authentic Tamale Pie, though it seems I’m more confused about authentic Mexican than I thought!

Tamale Pie

Oven Temp: 375º

  • ½ lb. lean ground beef
  • ½ lb. hot chorizo sausage (about 2 links), out of the casings
  • 1 green bell pepper, seeded, chopped
  • 1 yellow onion, chopped
  • 2 poblano peppers, sliced (reserve some slices for decoration later)
  • 3 cloves garlic, minced
  • 4 oz. frozen sweet yellow corn (about ¼ of a bag)
  • 6 oz. Monterey Jack cheese, shredded
  • 1 tsp. ground chili pepper
  • 1 tsp. cumin
  • ¼ tsp. cinnamon

for the topping:

  • 2 cups water
  • 1 cup cornmeal
  • ½ tsp. salt
  • 1 T. butter

In a medium dutch oven, begin to saute onions and peppers (reserving a few slices of the poblano for later). When onions are translucent, add garlic, ground beef, and chorizo and break it up into peices. Cook for 10 minutes then add cheese, corn, and spices.

Meanwhile: Bring water, cornmeal, and salt to a boil in a small saucepan. Simmer, stirring, until cornmeal thickens. Turn off heat, add butter, and stir.

Using a rubber spatula, spread cornmeal mixture over the meat mixture. Decorate with reserved poblano slices. Bake, uncovered, in the oven for 40 minutes. ¡Buen apetito!

11 thoughts on “American Tamale Pie”

  1. Ha! I semi-recently blogged about tamale pie, too. I had never heard of it before, either, but was looking for lard-less tamale recipes and came across the infamous “tamale pie” so I decided to make my own version with masa harina. It was tasty albeit not at all Mexican. Your version looks great!

  2. Nice, this couldn’t have come at a better time – we have ground beef defrosting in the fridge and I was trying to figure out what on earth I could do with it – I needed a new inspiration 🙂 This looks terrific, I’ll give it a go tonight!

  3. i still never had a chance to taste Tamale. I guess it is a very American thing, and we Asians get around to eating only the very famous ones. Its nice when hubby can can cook.Mine does too, and we so often end up arguing in the kitchen over whose recipe is better 😛

  4. Gotta love Mexican – authentic American or Mexican 🙂 Looks yummy (and I don’t even eat meat).. hubby does though, so am sure he will love this as we both crave anything that has some sort of mexican flavor!

  5. This posting cracked me up.
    Tamale pie is definitely a yummy dead-of-winter daring-Midwesterner covered dish–right hemisphere, wrong country, a distorted sort of Mexican-ish in the same way that Marquez (Colombian living in Mexico) and Borges (Argentinian) are Spanish.

    Thanks for the recipe, nevertheless! =~)

  6. beck- Glad I could amuse you! I’ve actually gotten a few emails about the Colombian and Argentinian thing—so I’ve changed the blog to fix any offense. Didn’t mean to sound small-minded, I swear I know where my favorite authors come from!!! 😀 Thanks for reading!! Robin

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s