Butterscotch pudding.

I’m not sure why I’m in love with butterscotch pudding.  There’s the deliciousness, there’s that, but I thinks there’s something more to it.  I’m drawn to butterscotch pudding, I feel it in my soul.  It’s as if I grew up with the fondest memories of butterscotch pudding, which I hardly ever had (don’t remember ever having.)  Maybe I wish I did.  Maybe it’s those Werther Original’s commercials, where the old man shares a Werther’s with his grandson, off in his own little world of memory and happiness.

And I’m not sure I even love the taste; good as it is—sweet, buttery—it’s almost too much.  I feel almost too much like a kid eating it.  With some whipped cream on top, a good blanket to snuggle into, and a good book to read, it’s almost too sweet, too much, this butterscotch pudding.

Which isn’t to say your shouldn’t try it.  Especially with a few big spoonfuls of lightly whipped cream. Especially if you have fond memories of butterscotch—real or televisionary—that you’d like to revisit.  You don’t need to add whiskey into it—the origin of the scotch part of the word butterscotch is murky—but if you happen to have a bottle of Balvenie 10, you’d be crazy not to use it.  The spicy, vanilla notes of this scotch were simply made for brown sugar and butter.  It adds a hint of warmth, an extra jolt of comfort.  Whatever you do though, make sure you have the whipped cream, the blanket and a comfy couch, and preferably a good book.  Maybe even a tumbler filled with whiskey on the side table, like I did, to, you know, remind myself that I’m all grown up.

Butterscotch Pudding

adapted from Gourmet

  • 1/2 cup packed dark brown sugar
  • 2 tablespoons plus 2 tsp cornstarch
  • 1 1/2 cups whole milk
  • 1/2 cup heavy cream
  • 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, cut into bits
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon of non-peaty scotch-whiskey
  • lightly sweetened whipped cream

Whisk together brown sugar, cornstarch, and 1/4 tsp salt in a heavy medium saucepan, then whisk in milk and cream. Bring to a boil over medium heat, whisking frequently, then boil, whisking, 1 minute. Remove from heat and whisk in butter, vanilla, and scotch. Pour into a bowl, then cover surface with buttered wax paper and chill until cold, at least 1 1/2 hours.

22 thoughts on “Butterscotch pudding.”

  1. I know the feeling of being nostalgic about something I never ate as a kid. Happens to me all the time—probably because I was a picky kid. This sounds delicious and with only 1 teaspoon of scotch in the recipe, I think it’s only reasonable to have a glass on the side.

  2. For me pudding was a favorite but fleeting childhood treat. There were five of us, and a box of pudding didn’t cut it. At that time, making it from scratch was not even on the radar. These days, I have a favorite chocolate scratch pudding recipe that I make when I want to soothe myself, or my son. We could both eat it until we burst from the goodness of it.

    I like that this recipe doesn’t use eggs. I will give it a whirl, sans scotch. I’m sure it will still do the trick.

    1. I was a boxed-pudding child too. And though I love the vanilla, it really doesn’t hold a candle. From-scratch chocolate is next on my list.

      Hope it does the trick indeed, Kate. : )

  3. I agree, there is something about butterscotch pudding that is incredibly enticing. Other than banana cream, it’s my favorite flavor. Is it supposed to look green in the first few pictures? Or is that just my monitor….

    1. It’s not supposed to. Do you use a PC? I’m on a Mac and I find they are usually less blue. I do need to tweak that though—uploaded before my morning coffee today. : )

  4. Oh! How I love pudding. When I was younger, we had these tupperware pudding pop containers that my mom would make instant JELLO pudding, and then freeze it to make a popsicle. Butterscotch was almost ALWAYS my number one choice. I have never thought to make homemade, though.

    1. Pudding pops!! I’ve forgotten all about those! I think they just may be better than regular pudding, can’t wait til it gets warmer out so I can enjoy them out in the sun. : D

  5. I have never even heard of butterscotch pudding it looks so good!
    I love making chocolate pudding with real whipped cream!
    I am going to have to try this!:)

  6. Love butterscotch pudding too! Mario Batali makes one at his Pizzeria Mozza, and he adds just a smidge of sea salt to it. Out of this world.

  7. My sister had been requesting Butterscotch Pudding for her Birthday treat. The kind with a skin she said. I did try a recipe & although it came out ok, this sounds more like “mom used to make” 🙂
    I can”t wait to make it tonight as a Suprise offering. Her Birthday was the 3rd, so it’s like a week long party ! 🙂 I agree with Anticiplate, a Jello box didn’t go far. We often dug under the top to try to sneek more. Making caves in the bowl. Great fun! Good times!~

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s