Simple tomato salad.

When I first started to throw dinner parties, just a few years ago now, I would work myself into such a tizzy over the damn things, overextending myself, liable to melt into a pool of nervous tears halfway through.  I needed to make enough food to feed an army, in the vain hope that everyone would be so enraptured by my talents that they’d eat until it was all gone.  I chose recipes that were vastly above my skill level, deciding on them before even hitting the market. There’d be hard-to-find ingredients hailing from Asia, or Morocco; cheeses I was supposed to use though I’d never tried them (and had no sense of their potency). And when something would go wrong—I couldn’t find the ingredient or hated the cheese—I would turn into a ball of nerves, believing there was nothing I could do, that I didn’t have any other recipes to turn to.

Thankfully, those times are past.  Lots of dinner parties, and problems, later, I’ve learned that you go to market without a set plan, with your head full of possibilities.  I still follow recipes, but loosely.  I keep a pantry full of basic ingredients—for a basic vinaigrette, a basic sauce—and I revert to the simplest food whenever a problem arises (or even, before.)  After a few years of chefs and cookbooks drilling simplicity into my head, I’ve finally come around.

The lovely thing is, simple food doesn’t have to taste simple.  Duh. But I think that fact eludes most fledgling cooks, entering a world of complicated techniques and endless cuisines.  It eluded me, that’s for sure.  I think I picked complicated recipes because I couldn’t bear the thought of screwing up simple, while making a mistakes in advanced cooking were easily shrugged off.  Simple can be scary.  But simple food is worth learning.

Especially in the summer, when you don’t want to spend too much time cooking (I certainly prefer swimming), and when you can take full advantage of the tomatoes you (or your magical elves) grow in the garden, and when even the measliest herb garden will do its part.  During the dog days of summer, simple isn’t just best, it’s the only option.  This simple tomato salad is a must too, or at least it was for me, because I got to spend a lazy summer day driving around the pretty countryside along the Delaware river, picking up tomatoes down the road, and a fancy goat cheese at the market; to come home and feel very accomplished while I picked French sorrel and herbs from my little potted garden.

I used a variety of tomatoes; some from down the road, some from the little gourmet shop where I got the cheese, and one from a fancy grocery store.  We did a blind tasting before making the salad and it was hard to judge these tomatoes, they were so different — though surprisingly, the fancy grocery store won by a small margin. (They did cost about 4 dollars per small tomato: don’t judge me people, I knew full-well it was ridiculous!).  I also used a variety of herbs: lemon thyme, a few leaves of peppermint, basil, parsley, a load of chives, and some very biting sorrel.  The goat cheese, a pepper crusted capricchio, was a perfect addition; it made the watery juice of the tomatoes taste creamy and it tempered the bite of sorrel.  Pick a goat cheese that  packs a load of creaminess and some sort or herb or spice crust is a nice.  And if you don’t have an herb garden, you can just use whatever herbs are on your shopping list, two of them at minimum, because without the variety of herbs, you risk your good, simple salad turning bored.  We ate this with a chicken slathered with marsacapone that practically knocked me off my chair, which I’ll write about next, promise.  It was one of my favorite meals I’ve made, summery and, duh, simple.

Simple Tomato Salad

serves 2-3

3-4 heirloom or garden tomatoes, tasted for quality
small bunch sorrel leaves (or watercress or arugula)
handful of mixed herbs, such as mint, basil, lemon thyme, and chives
soft goat cheese, preferably with a pepper crust
balsamic vinegar, for drizzling
good quality olive oil, for drizzling
fleur de sel, or kosher salt
freshly ground black pepper

Slice tomatoes into thick slices and season with a bit of salt.  Leave in a colandar to drain for 15 minutes.  Toss them around so any excess water comes off, then arrange them on a platter.  Tuck the sorrel leaves under and around the tomatoes.  Tear or chop up the herbs and scatter over tomatoes.  Crumble the goat cheese over tomatoes.  Drizzle balsamic and olive oil over the tomatoes and season to taste with fleur de sel and fresh black pepper.


23 thoughts on “Simple tomato salad.”

  1. Mmm, yes, love the idea of goat cheese instead of mozzarella…
    Also love realizing how much easier entertaining has gotten over the last few years!

  2. We don’t know how lucky we have it: the tomato crop in the Northeast has been devastated by late rot and most farmers’ markets in NY are selling tomatoes for $4/lb. The Delaware River valley area of NJ and PA has been largely spared and good tomatoes are plentiful right now. I buy mine at Slack Farm in Furlong, where all varieties are $2.50/lb or 3 lbs for $7. Last weekend, they had a few heirlooms that I believe are called Cherokee Chocolates, which had a variegated color ranging from brownish-black (hence, the name Cherokee Chocolate) to orange to green. They also had Big Boys and several varieties of smaller tomatoes. We also did tomato salads for nearly every meal with a simple extra virgin olive oil/salt/pepper/basil/oregano drizzle. Ohmygod, were they fabulous. Just wish it could stay early August for half the year.

    1. Wow, didn’t realize about the rot… we are lucky indeed.

      I usually get my tomatoes at the farm stand on 29 right by my house in Stockton. Just a family that puts their extras in a bin for a dollar a pound or so… and they are fabulous. I do need to go out and try some others while I can though…

  3. Oh, yes, it sounds like I entertained the same way that you did. And, I am slowly coming around too. As to the tomatoes, we are having a terrible crop so I think I will just have pictures of salads like this.

  4. Marvellous.

    Of course, we all need to go through that manic phase in order to free ourselves up. If you had seen me in my twenties…always glad it gets easier.

    No judgement from me re your precious tomato cargo. I’d have fallen for them at that price, too.

    1. Thanks, Lucy.

      At least I was buying them in-season for that much, so much better than buying an over-priced, flavorless one in the middle of winter (something I used to do all to often, before I learned more about food.)

  5. Oh yes! I love this type of tomato salad! In fact, I am doing a series on my blog of my favorite tomato salads and they are, as yours is, simple…and yummy! Love your little herb garden 🙂

  6. I really like you comments about simplicity and could not agree more with such a thoughtful post. Your simple tomato salad is lovely. Greg

  7. I could eat that whole plate! I like the way you presented this post with a view of the herbs on the porch, the beauty of the tomatoes on a wooden table, etc. Simple, yes, but beautiful.

  8. I don’t know if there’s anything more delicious than a simple tomato salad. Love the idea of adding sorrel!

  9. I love this salad! Those tomatoes are just gorgeous. I need to get mine planted in September so I can have some ripe for Christmas!!!

  10. Oh, this looks great, Robin. I love the way those tomatoes look.

    I just remembered something. Do you know the cheese shop on Sullivan Street just below Houston, on the west side of the street, in the Village? It’s Italian. I don’t know if it’s still there; I used to go there all the time because (partly) I lived across Houston St. from it, but really because of the smoked mozzerella they used to make (i.e. themselves). Also the ricotta. Fantastic cheeses, great hot wrinkled black olives too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s